Order now

Experience Cheesecake Crafted with Tradition and Care

Crafted fresh, never frozen, with premium ingredients to make every moment heavenly

Place an order

Experience Cheesecake Crafted with Tradition and Care

Crafted fresh, never frozen, with premium ingredients to make every moment heavenly

Place an order

Delight in every bite of our custom cheesecakes

Timeless recipes, fresh ingredients, unforgettable flavors

Cole’s Custom Cheesecakes brings together families, friends, and communities through the shared joy of exceptional desserts. With recipes inspired by cherished family traditions and crafted using only the finest ingredients—like imported butter and Philadelphia cream cheese—our cheesecakes are fresh, never frozen, and perfectly balanced, ensuring every occasion is memorable. Place your order today and taste the difference that love and tradition make.

Valentine’s Day Specials

Heart Shaped Cheesecake with Cheesecake Filled Chocolate Covered Strawberries

Heart Shaped Cheesecake & Strawberries Treat Box

Valentine’s Day Bundle 3 Mini Cheesecakes

Valentine’s Day Mini Cheesecake Bundle

Cole's Custom Cheesecakes - Boxed Cheesecake Filled Chocolate Covered Strawberries

Cheesecake Filled Chocolate Covered Strawberries

Don't settle for a dessert that falls flat

  • Forgettable Flavors

    Generic desserts can leave your guests unimpressed and your event unremarkable.

  • Artificial Tasting Treats

    Mass-produced, overly sweet cheesecakes often have a dense texture and artificial taste that overshadow the joy of indulgence.

  • Stale Sweets

    Frozen cheesecakes lose their freshness, leaving you with a disappointing, less-than-perfect dessert experience.

  • Forgettable Flavors

    Generic desserts can leave your guests unimpressed and your event unremarkable.

  • Artificial Tasting Treats

    Mass-produced, overly sweet cheesecakes often have a dense texture and artificial taste that overshadow the joy of indulgence.

  • Stale Sweets

    Frozen cheesecakes lose their freshness, leaving you with a disappointing, less-than-perfect dessert experience.

Our irresistible selections

Turtle Cheesecake

9" Custom Cheesecakes

Perfect for holidays, family gatherings, or intimate celebrations, our 9” cheesecakes are the epitome of indulgence, crafted to perfection with high-quality, fresh ingredients like imported butter and Philadelphia cream cheese. Each slice offers a velvety, melt-in-your-mouth experience with a perfectly balanced, light sweetness and a buttery crust that’s loved by everyone. Designed to impress, these luscious cheesecakes bring people together, leaving your guests craving more with every flavorful bite.

Shop Now
Learn More
Cole's Custom Cheesecakes - Mini Lemon Blueberry Cheesecakes

Mini Cheesecakes

Ideal for weddings, corporate events, or elegant celebrations, our mini cheesecakes deliver a luxurious, bite-sized taste of heaven. Made with fresh, premium ingredients and never frozen, these scrumptious treats feature a silky cheesecake filling paired with a buttery, crisp crust. Offering the same rich and light taste as our larger cakes, they’re a divine way to elevate any special occasion and leave your guests with a memorable, indulgent experience.

Shop Now
Learn More
Cole's Custom Cheesecakes - Boxed Cheesecake Filled Chocolate Covered Strawberries

Cheesecake Filled Strawberries

Experience a delightful fusion of flavors with our cheesecake-filled strawberries. Perfectly fresh and juicy, these strawberries are filled with our signature creamy cheesecake for a truly indulgent treat. Available in a variety of options, they can be enjoyed as they are or dressed up with a chocolate coating for an extra layer of decadence. Perfect for parties, special occasions, or a unique gift, these strawberries are a crowd-pleasing favorite that bring sweetness and sophistication to any event.

Shop Now

Ordering made easy

1. Browse and Choose Your Flavor

Start by exploring our menu of signature and specialty cheesecakes. Whether you need a full-size masterpiece or some cute, bite-sized minis, we have the perfect option for every occasion.

2. Place Your Custom Order

Once you’ve selected your cheesecake, place your order online or give us a call. We’ll ensure every detail is tailored to your needs, from flavor selection to special requests for your event.

3. Savor the Unmatched Freshness

Pick up your freshly baked cheesecake and enjoy! Our high-quality, never-frozen ingredients ensure a delightful dessert experience that will impress your guests and create lasting memories.

Delightful words from our customers

This cheesecake is beyond delicious! With each bite, its creamy texture and rich flavor captivate my taste buds. It’s a dessert that leaves a lasting impression, and I find myself craving its indulgen…

Read More

Jae C.

Yummy! This cheesecake is a taste sensation! Creamy, rich, and utterly irresistible, it’s a dessert experience like no other. One bite and you’ll be hooked on its indulgent flavor. Will definitely ord…

Read More

Leanne C.

This cheesecake is a true delight! Creamy, flavorful, and utterly irresistible, it’s a dessert that exceeds expectations. With every bite, you’re transported to a world of sweet indulgence and culinar…

Read More

Nick D.

I recently had the pleasure of tasting the raspberry lemon cheesecake from Cole’s Custom Cheesecakes, and I must say, it was absolutely delicious! I was so impressed by the flavor and the texture of…

Read More

Drew T. Jackson

I was blessed to win free mini cheesecakes competition and we collected our prize yesterday. We had key lime & turtle pecan cheesecakes and oh my goodness they were delicious. We shared them with a …

Read More

Sarah Jay

Cole’s Cheesecakes are incredible. I was initially drawn to them by the sweet potato flavor since I’m from the South and had never heard of it. It did not disappoint!
But his new summer flavor,…

Read More

Justin Winstead

My family surprised me with Cole’s Custom Cheesecake for my birthday! Since they have so many amazing flavors, they could not resist ordering a large sweet potato cheesecake and lemon raspberry mi…

Read More

Denise Visingardi

Add a review:

    Cole's Custom Cheesecakes new business of the year 2023

    Best New Business

    Cole’s Custom Cheesecakes was honored to be recognized as the Best New Business in Keller, TX, for 2023. This award reflects our dedication to delivering exceptional desserts and building meaningful connections with our community. We are grateful for the support of our loyal customers who have made this achievement possible.

    Treat yourself

    Ready to experience pure bliss?

    Don’t wait to elevate your next celebration with our fresh, indulgent cheesecakes. Crafted with high-quality ingredients and a passion for flavor, each cake is a heavenly experience. Place your order now or reach out to discuss custom options.

    Order nowContact us

    From our kitchen to yours

    FAQ

    We specialize in 9” custom cheesecakes, mini cheesecakes, and a variety of specialty flavors to suit every occasion.

    Yes, all our cheesecakes are made with fresh, high-quality ingredients and never frozen.
    Absolutely! We love creating custom orders to make your event special.
    Our cheesecakes are made using premium ingredients like imported butter and Philadelphia cream cheese, creating a light and balanced flavor with a buttery, perfectly balanced crust.
    Currently, we offer convenient pickup to ensure your cheesecake remains fresh and perfect for your event.
    We recommend placing your order at least 72 hours in advance to guarantee freshness and availability.

    Please contact us with your dietary needs, and we’ll do our best to accommodate them.

    We require a 48-hour notice for cancellations to issue a full refund.
    Yes, we offer tastings for large event orders. Contact us for more details.
    Our cheesecakes are currently available exclusively through direct orders on our website.

    Have a question or special request?

      0
        0
        Your Cart
        Your cart is emptyReturn to Shop
        Continue Shopping