Luxurious cheesecake creations for every celebration
Crafted to perfection
At Cole’s Custom Cheesecakes, our 9″ Custom Cheesecakes are a tribute to timeless family recipes, crafted to make every moment special. We use only high-quality ingredients like imported butter and Philadelphia cream cheese to deliver a velvety, perfectly balanced flavor. Whether it’s a holiday gathering or an intimate celebration, each cheesecake promises a melt-in-your-mouth experience. Place your order today to taste the difference made by generations of baking tradition.
Why settle for less than perfection?
Discover Our Signature 9" Cheesecakes
Fresh, High-Quality Ingredients
Our cheesecakes are made using only the freshest, premium ingredients, like imported butter and Philadelphia cream cheese. The result is a velvety texture and rich, creamy flavor that never disappoints. We never use artificial flavors or preservatives, ensuring each cake is as natural and delicious as possible.
Perfectly Balanced Sweetness
We believe that a cheesecake should be light and not overly sweet. Our unique recipes ensure a perfect balance of tangy and sweet, complemented by a buttery crust that adds the right amount of crunch. Every bite is a delightful experience, leaving your guests craving more.
Handcrafted with Love and Tradition
Every cheesecake we bake is a labor of love, inspired by family recipes passed down through generations. Cole’s grandmother’s influence lives on in each creation, bringing warmth and connection to every celebration. Our cheesecakes aren’t just desserts; they’re heartfelt memories shared with loved ones.
What makes our cheesecakes extraordinary
Our simple ordering process
1. Explore Our Menu
Browse our selection of 9″ Custom Cheesecakes and choose your desired flavors and special requests. Our detailed menu offers something for every occasion.
2. Place Your Order
Easily place your order online or by phone. We’ll walk you through any customization options to ensure your cake is perfect for your event.
3. Pick Up and Enjoy
Once your cheesecake is freshly baked, pick it up and get ready to impress your guests. Each cake is crafted with care to provide a memorable dessert experience.
The proof is in the cheesecake
At Cole’s Custom Cheesecakes, we blend generations of tradition with a dedication to unmatched freshness and meticulous attention to detail. Our recipes, passed down through Cole’s family, infuse each bite with a sense of nostalgia and heartfelt connection. We use only the freshest, natural ingredients, never freezing our cakes, to ensure a melt-in-your-mouth experience that stands apart from the rest. From the buttery, golden crust to the perfect balance of tangy and sweet flavors, every cheesecake is crafted with precision and care.
Get your fix!
Craving a slice of heaven?
Don't settle for anything less than the best. Order your 9" Custom Cheesecake now and make your next celebration unforgettable.
Order nowLet's talk flavorsFAQ
Our cheesecakes are handcrafted with family recipes, using fresh, high-quality ingredients and never frozen, ensuring a rich and creamy texture.
Please place your order at least 72 hours in advance to ensure availability and freshness.
Yes, we can accommodate special flavor requests and dietary considerations. Contact us to discuss your needs.
We typically require a 72-hour notice, but feel free to call us to see if we can accommodate your request.
Currently, we offer pickup only to guarantee freshness and quality.
Absolutely! Our 9″ Custom Cheesecakes are perfect for celebrations, from holidays to intimate gatherings.
Our classic New York-style and seasonal specialties like Pumpkin Caramel are fan favorites.
We do our best to accommodate dietary needs, such as gluten-free crusts or reduced sugar. Contact us to learn more.
Keep your cheesecake refrigerated and consume it within 5-7 days for optimal freshness.
We occasionally offer tasting events. Check our website or contact us for more information.